Contact the team at FWB to discuss your individual or company requirements, or to discover more about our specialist services.
Sustainability in the Boardroom: beyond compliance to purpose, materiality and good governance
19 November 2026
- Leadership Development
- Education
For Boards, understanding sustainability is no longer simply about keeping pace with ESG regulation and reporting. In the second session of FWB’s 2026 NXD Development Programme, Dr Sarah Ivory and Amanda Young explored why Boards need to understand what is material to their organisation, how sustainability connects to purpose and long-term success and, crucially, the questions Non-Executive Directors should be asking.
Sustainability can be a difficult subject for Boards to navigate.
The terminology has evolved. Reporting requirements continue to develop. Environmental, social and governance considerations can encompass everything from climate and biodiversity to employees, supply chains, communities, human rights and responsible business practices.
Faced with that breadth and complexity, it can be tempting for individual Board members to regard sustainability as a specialist issue, one best left to the sustainability team, a particular committee or those with technical expertise.
Dr Sarah Ivory directly challenged that thinking. Reflecting on her experience presenting on climate change and sustainability to Boards, Sarah described seeing Board members who were highly engaged, those who were sceptical and those who appeared to regard the subject as someone else’s responsibility.
Her message to the latter was clear:
“If you become one of the people who just look down and decide it’s someone else’s job, not only are you missing out on opportunities, but also, you’re not doing your job as a Board member.”
The role of an NXD is not necessarily to become the organisation’s sustainability expert.
It is to understand enough to ask the right questions.
Start with what matters
One challenge of ESG is its sheer breadth.
An organisation could potentially engage with dozens of environmental and social issues. But attempting to address everything equally can make sustainability less, rather than more, useful as a strategic tool.
For Sarah, the key is materiality.
“I’m much more interested in how organisations are responding to ESG or sustainability issues based on what is material and what matters.”
This requires Boards to consider sustainability through more than one lens.
What impact could an issue such as climate change, resource scarcity or changing societal expectations have on the organisation? That may present a risk, but it could also create an opportunity.
Equally, what impact does the organisation have on that issue through its operations, people, products, supply chains or investments?
This concept of double materiality helps move the Board conversation away from sustainability as an abstract agenda and towards the issues that genuinely matter to the organisation and those it affects.
As Sarah explained, focusing only on risk can also provide an incomplete picture:
“There will be a lot of focus on risk, perhaps, but we need to counter that with opportunity, otherwise it can fall off the radar.”
For Boards, the challenge is therefore not to ask, what are we doing about sustainability? It is to ask: which sustainability issues are material to this organisation, what risks and opportunities do they create, and how are we responding?
Before ESG comes purpose
Materiality, however, raises a more fundamental question: What is the organisation ultimately trying to achieve?
For Sarah, discussions around sustainability, measurement and reporting cannot be separated from organisational purpose.
“We can’t do any of that until we decide on the organisation’s purpose, what I call addressing the why. Why does the organisation exist?”
During the session, participants were challenged to consider three possible reasons for a business’s existence: to make a profit; to produce goods and services; or to support a thriving society.
The intention was not necessarily to identify one universally correct answer. Instead, the exercise highlighted the importance of Boards being clear about their organisation’s purpose.
Profit appeared across the different scenarios discussed during the session, leading Sarah to make an important distinction:
“Making profit isn’t the question. It’s why you exist, not whether you make profit.”
For a Board, that distinction matters. Purpose provides a reference point against which strategic choices, investment decisions, risk appetite and sustainability priorities can be tested. Sarah went further, arguing that alignment with purpose should be fundamental to Board composition itself:
“I almost think you shouldn’t join the Board unless you agree with the purpose of the organisation, and the Board should be very clear on why it exists.”
Board members will, of course, disagree about how an organisation should achieve its objectives. Constructive challenge is essential to good governance. But if there is fundamental disagreement about why the organisation exists, reaching alignment on long-term strategy becomes considerably more difficult.
Compliance is the starting point, not the whole conversation
In the second half of the session, Amanda Young brought the discussion into the practical realities of Board oversight.
She started by saying NXDs need to consider sustainability through two connected lenses: the organisation’s regulatory obligations and the issues that are specifically material to the business.
Understanding the regulatory landscape is essential.
As sustainability reporting and disclosure requirements evolve, Boards need confidence that management understands which requirements apply to the organisation and that appropriate processes are in place to meet them.
But compliance alone does not answer the strategic question.
Amanda encouraged NXDs to move beyond asking whether the organisation is meeting its reporting obligations and consider how sustainability connects to long-term success, purpose and risk.
This means asking not only what we must report, but what actually matters to this business. That can include financially material risks, such as the impact that environmental or social issues may have on the organisation, alongside the organisation’s own impacts, which may affect its reputation, relationships, customers or broader licence to operate.
For NXDs faced with an increasingly complex sustainability landscape, Amanda suggested beginning with something relatively straightforward:
“The starting point is, what are the regulatory requirements we have to meet as an organisation? And the exec should be able to tell you that.”
If they cannot, that itself should prompt further Board scrutiny.
Governance needs ownership
Understanding what matters is only part of the Board’s role. Clarity is also needed on who is responsible.
Sustainability can sit within several Board structures. It may be integrated into the full Board agenda, overseen through audit and risk, considered by a dedicated sustainability committee or embedded across the organisation’s wider business model.
No single structure will suit every organisation. What matters is that the chosen model is deliberate, proportionate to the organisation’s material risks and clearly connected to strategy.
Amanda highlighted one potential danger of making sustainability everybody’s responsibility: it can inadvertently become nobody’s accountability. Whether sustainability sits with the full Board or within a committee structure, Boards need to understand where responsibility lies.
“You need to be very clear about where things sit and who has accountability.”
For Amanda, audit and risk structures can provide a particularly useful home for many of these discussions.
- Are material sustainability risks reflected in the organisation’s risk register?
- Are appropriate controls in place?
- Is the Board receiving the information it needs?
- And are sustainability considerations genuinely integrated into strategic decisions, rather than operating in isolation?
These are governance questions as much as sustainability questions.
Ask the ‘daft’ questions
A recurring theme across the NXD Development Programme is that effective Non-Executive Directors do not need to be the technical expert in every subject that reaches the Boardroom.
They do, however, need enough understanding to challenge, probe and recognise when more information is required.
Amanda’s advice was refreshingly simple:
“Be curious, ask questions, ask the daft questions. Really important.”
That curiosity becomes particularly important when Boards are presented with large volumes of sustainability data, metrics and reporting. A dashboard full of numbers does not necessarily provide insight.
Amanda suggested one of the most powerful questions an NXD can ask is: So what?
- Why is this information relevant to the organisation?
- What does it tell the Board?
- What evidence or assurance sits behind it?
- What could go wrong?
- And what decision should this information inform?
The quality of Board challenge does not depend on asking the most technically sophisticated question in the room. Often, it depends on asking the question that reconnects detailed information to strategy, risk and purpose.
Asking the right question at the right time
Another important dimension of effective challenge is timing.
Amanda cautioned that even the right question can have limited impact if it is raised too late in a decision-making process.
“Timing beats content.”
If an NXD identifies a significantly material issue, waiting until the relevant item appears during a Board meeting may leave insufficient time for proper discussion, evidence gathering or challenge. That can mean raising questions with the Chair or executive team in advance, ensuring sufficient Board time is allocated, and using minutes to document concerns and agreed actions.
The Board’s role is not to perform management’s job. It is to ensure that management has done the necessary work, that appropriate governance processes have been followed and that the Board has sufficient information to make a properly informed decision.
That distinction came to life during the session through a case study involving a significant proposed investment with financial benefits alongside carbon, biodiversity, water, and supply-chain considerations.
The conclusion was not that a Board should automatically reject an investment carrying sustainability risks.
It was that the Board must understand those risks before approving it.
- What due diligence has been undertaken?
- How does the investment align with strategy?
- How does it affect existing public commitments?
- Where does accountability sit?
- Have the correct governance channels been followed?
- And does the Board genuinely have enough information to make the decision?
Sustainability is a Board issue
Perhaps one of the most useful conclusions from the session was also one of the simplest. NXDs do not need to know everything about sustainability. But they cannot opt out of understanding it.
As Sarah reflected towards the end of the discussion, Board members may not always know in advance when the sustainability knowledge they have developed will become relevant. A climate issue, supply-chain concern or environmental risk can quickly become part of an investment, strategy or governance decision.
At that point, the ability to ask the right questions matters. For Boards, good sustainability governance therefore starts neither with a reporting framework nor a list of ESG initiatives.
It starts with clarity:
- Why does this organisation exist?
- What sustainability issues are genuinely material to its long-term success and impact?
- What are our regulatory responsibilities?
- Where does accountability sit?
- And are we asking the right questions early enough to influence the decisions that matter?
Sustainability may be increasingly complex. The Board’s responsibility is not to master every technical detail. It is to ensure that complexity does not prevent good governance.
About the NXD Development Programme
This article draws on the second session of the 2026 NXD Development Programme, “The Role of Boards in Understanding ESG Compliance”, with Dr Sarah Ivory and Amanda Young.
Sarah specialises in climate change, sustainability and executive education and is the author of Becoming a Critical Thinker. Amanda has more than 30 years’ experience in sustainability and responsible investment across executive and Non-Executive roles and is currently Chief Sustainability Officer at Arrow Global.
Now in its seventh year, the NXD Development Programme is delivered by FWB Executive Search in partnership with the University of Edinburgh Business School. Designed for both experienced Non-Executive Directors and those developing or aspiring towards an NXD portfolio, the programme explores the challenges and opportunities shaping today’s Board agenda.
Each year, the programme is developed in collaboration with leading academics, Chairs and Non-Executive Directors, combining current business school thinking with the practical experience and skills required around the Boardroom table. Sessions are interactive and designed to encourage participants to learn not only from expert contributors, but from the experience and perspectives of one another.
The 2026 programme runs from September to December, with six two-hour online sessions exploring organisational design and AI, ESG and sustainability, the global AI revolution, cybersecurity, Board effectiveness and geopolitical literacy, alongside an in-person session in Edinburgh on 3 December.
Registration remains open for upcoming sessions, held online every two weeks until early December.